Every Claim We’ve Checked
All 88 claims we have checked, grouped by subject — supplements, training, sweeteners, diets, sleep and the rest — each with its confidence rating.
Every claim on this site has been checked against the primary research and given one of four confidence ratings. There are 88 of them so far, and this page is all of them, grouped by subject.
If you would rather browse by how confident we are, the Established, Supported, Preliminary and Unsupported pages do that instead.
- established (12)
Settled. Large, consistent evidence and the direction is not contested. - supported (23)
Real, with good evidence behind it — but smaller or less certain than Established. - preliminary (19)
Something is here and nobody can tell you what yet. Unresolved on purpose. - unsupported (34)
Checked, and the evidence does not back the claim.
Sweeteners (7)
Sugar substitutes, and the studies people quote about them.
- Are Sugar Alcohols Bad For You? The Real Problem Is Digestive
supported - Are Artificial Sweeteners Bad For You? The WHO Hedged — Here’s Why
preliminary - Is Diet Soda Bad For You? Better Than Regular — With One Catch
preliminary - Is Erythritol Bad For You? The One Sweetener Worth Watching
preliminary - Is Stevia Bad For You? “Natural” Is Not a Safety Category
preliminary - Is Sucralose Bad For You? The DNA Headlines Skipped One Sentence
preliminary - Is Aspartame Bad For You? Two WHO Reports, One Headline
unsupported
Supplements (23)
What the tub claims, and what the trials found.
- Creatine Benefits: They Screened 250 Supplements. Two Survived.
established - Does Creatine Make You Gain Weight? Yes — 1.9 Pounds. The Fat Didn’t Move.
established - How Much Creatine Should You Take? 3 To 5 Grams — And You’re Already Most Of The Way There
established - How Much Protein to Build Muscle: The Famous 1.62 Ceiling Was Never Statistically Significant
established - Is Creatine Safe? Yes — And the Blood Test Explains the Panic
established - Collagen Benefits: It Does Work on Skin. 95% of the Evidence Is in Women.
supported - Creatine for Women: 0.8 lb of Lean Mass in Nine Months. That Is the Bulk You Were Warned About.
supported - Does Protein Keep You Full? Yes — But a Potato Beat Everything
supported - How Much Vitamin D Should I Take? The Big Trials Mostly Tested People Who Were Not Short of It.
supported - Magnesium Benefits: It Lowers Blood Pressure. It Does Not Fix Your Cramps.
supported - Protein for Fat Loss: It Works — Your Target Is Probably a Third Too High
supported - Ashwagandha Benefits: The Cortisol Drops. Feeling Better Is a Separate Question.
preliminary - Colostrum Benefits: The One Study That Moved Body Fat Used 60 Grams a Day. It Moved 0.4%.
preliminary - Does Zinc Help With Colds? Cochrane’s Most Certain Finding Was a Side Effect.
preliminary - Berberine Benefits: “Nature’s Ozempic” Is 1.9 Pounds. Ozempic Is 34.
unsupported - Do Fat Burners Work? 21 Trials, and the Effect Crosses Zero
unsupported - Does Creatine Cause Hair Loss? Nobody Checked The Hair Until 2025
unsupported - Does Creatine Help You Lose Weight? No — And It Will Move Your Scale the Wrong Way
unsupported - Fish Oil Benefits: The Real One Needs a Prescription
unsupported - Fish Oil vs Krill Oil: 64 Trials Found No Difference. The Absorption Study Has 12 People.
unsupported - Methylene Blue: Approved for a Poisoning Emergency. Fatal Cases Described With Antidepressants.
unsupported - NAD+ Supplements: The NAD Really Does Go Up. Almost Nothing Else Did.
unsupported - Sea Moss Benefits: The NIH’s Own Database Says No Medicinal Value Has Been Proven.
unsupported
Sleep, stress and recovery (12)
The parts of fat loss that happen when you are not training.
- Does Exercise Grow New Brain Cells? Yes — But Not Four Times Faster
supported - Does Lack of Sleep Cause Weight Gain? Yes — But Not How You Think
supported - How to Lower Cortisol: 87 Trials Say You Can. Cortisol May Not Be Why It Helps.
supported - Melatonin Dosage: Seven Minutes Faster to Sleep. The Bottles Ranged 83% Under to 478% Over.
supported - Blue Light and Deep Sleep: The Mechanism Is Real. The Muscle-Recovery Link Is Not.
preliminary - Box Breathing: It Works. So Did Everything Else They Tested.
preliminary - Metabolizing Stress: Why Your Cortisol Rhythm Might Be Sabotaging Fat Loss (and What to Do)
preliminary - Am I Overtraining? The Quiz — and Why No Score Can Answer It
unsupported - Cortisol Detox: The Treatment for Low Cortisol Is Being Given Cortisol.
unsupported - Cortisol Face and Cortisol Belly: Borrowed From a Disease That Affects 3 in a Million.
unsupported - High Cortisol Symptoms: Doctors Look for Purple Stretch Marks Over a Centimetre Wide. Not Tiredness.
unsupported - Sleep Hygiene: The Guideline Tells Doctors Not to Use It on Its Own.
unsupported
Meaning and connection (2)
- Ikigai: The Evidence Is Real. The Four-Circle Diagram Is Not Japanese.
supported - Blue Zones: Ten Regions on the List. One Has Never Been Studied.
preliminary
Heat, cold and light (5)
Saunas, ice baths, sweat suits and LED panels — things done to your body rather than by it.
- Does Sauna Burn Fat? The 400-Calorie Claim Came From a Wristwatch
preliminary - Red Light Therapy: 3 Inches Off the Waist. Body Fat Percentage Did Not Move.
preliminary - Sauna Benefits: The Numbers Are Striking. They Are Also All Finnish.
preliminary - Do Cold Plunges Burn Fat? What Human Research Actually Shows
unsupported - Does Sweating Burn Fat? No — 84% of It Leaves Through Your Lungs
unsupported
Diets and eating patterns (6)
Whole approaches to eating, checked one claim at a time.
- Does Fiber Help You Lose Weight? Yes — But the Average Is Easy to Misread
supported - Is Intermittent Fasting Better Than Just Eating Less?
preliminary - Do Detox Teas Work? Nobody Will Name the Toxin
unsupported - Does Cutting Carbs Burn Fat? The First Week Is Water
unsupported - Does Food Combining Work? One Trial in Ninety Years Says No
unsupported - Negative Calorie Foods: Celery Gets 86% of the Way There
unsupported
Hormones (7)
Blood levels, what they mean, and what moves them.
- How to Increase Testosterone Naturally: One Thing Works, and It Isn’t a Supplement
established - Does TRT Work? Clearly For Sex Drive. Not At All For Energy.
supported - Free vs Total Testosterone: A Normal Number Can Hide a Low One
supported - Do Testosterone Boosters Work? Not One Product Has Ever Been Tested
unsupported - Does Lifting Weights Increase Testosterone? Yes — And It Made No Difference
unsupported - Normal Testosterone Levels by Age: The 300 Cutoff Came From Older Men
unsupported - Should You Get Your Testosterone Tested? The Guideline Says No — In One Sentence
unsupported
Training (8)
Whether a given kind of exercise does what it is sold as doing.
- Does Lifting Weights Burn Fat? Yes — Your Scale Can’t See It
established - Does Running Burn Fat? Yes — But Not in the “Fat Burning Zone”
established - Does Walking Help You Lose Weight? Yes — 10,000 Steps Was a Trademark
supported - Grip Strength Predicts Death Better Than Blood Pressure. Squeezing Won’t Help.
supported - How Many Steps a Day? About 7,000 — and It Buys More Than Your Heart.
supported - Can You Burn Fat Off One Specific Body Part?
unsupported - Do Waist Trainers Work? Nine in Ten Took It Off Before the Trial Ended
unsupported - Does Cardio Burn Muscle? No — the People Doing Both Still Gained
unsupported
Body composition (2)
What your body is made of, and what the scale can and cannot see.
- Does Metabolism Slow With Age? Yes — at 60, Not 30
established - Does Muscle Weigh More Than Fat? Yes — But Not Enough to Explain Your Scale
established
Food and drink (16)
Individual foods, and the claims attached to them.
- Do Eggs Raise Cholesterol? Yes, About 5 mg/dL. The Fight Is Over Whether It Matters.
established - Is Canned Tuna Healthy? Yes — But You’re Probably Draining the Best Part
established - Beetroot Juice Benefits: 3.5 mmHg Off Blood Pressure. More Nitrate Made It Work Less.
supported - Does Chewing Gum Burn Calories? Yes — About 3.6 an Hour
supported - Is Oatmeal Good For Weight Loss? A Little. But Instant Oats Score Worse Than Granola.
supported - Is Olive Oil Good For You? Yes — But Not Compared To The Oils You’ve Been Told To Fear
supported - Is Red Meat Bad For You? Processed Meat Is The Real Answer
supported - Apple Cider Vinegar Benefits: One Is Real, One Was Retracted
preliminary - Does Coffee Help You Lose Weight? A Little — Nobody Knows How Much
preliminary - Does Drinking Water Help You Lose Weight? A Little. Just Not How They Said.
preliminary - Are Seed Oils Bad For You? Both Sides Are Quoting Half The Evidence
unsupported - Do You Need Electrolytes? The Cramp Claim Rests on 18 Case Reports and One Study of Ten.
unsupported - Does Lemon Water Help You Lose Weight? No. And It Doesn’t Alkalise You Either.
unsupported - How Much Water a Day? A 1945 Recommendation Lost Its Last Sentence.
unsupported - Is Canola Oil Bad For You? The Thing It’s Accused Of Was Bred Out Fifty Years Ago
unsupported - Is Vegetable Oil Bad For You? It Was — And That Part Has Been Banned
unsupported
Guides
Round-ups built from the verdicts above. They carry no confidence rating of their own, because a guide is not a single claim — each entry inside links to the verdict that justifies it.
- Best supplements for muscle growth — ranked by evidence tier. No products named, nothing for sale.
- Healthy habits — the habit verdicts regrouped by what they act on, each with what it costs you in time, money and effort.
Nothing here is medical advice. This is journalism — we read the research and report what it says. For anything about your own health, talk to a clinician.