
How Much Protein to Build Muscle: The Famous 1.62 Ceiling Was Never Statistically Significant
Protein supplementation works. In a 2018 review of 49 randomised trials and 1,863 people, all of them lifting weights, those taking it gained more fat-free mass — everything in the body that isn’t fat — than those who didn’t. The figure rests on about half of those trials: 26 comparisons of a protein group with a control group, 1,089 people by the review’s own count. [1]
The amount was 0.66 lb (0.30 kg). That is the average extra gain, over training that lasted thirteen weeks on average, and its 95% confidence interval — the range the true average probably sits in — runs from 0.2 to 1.1 lb (0.09 to 0.52 kg). Two-thirds of a pound. [1]
Which is real, and worth having, and nowhere near what the tub is implying.
It is also an average that hides a split. In people new to lifting the extra gain was 0.33 lb (0.15 kg), with an interval that just crosses zero (−0.04 to +0.68 lb); that is 22 of the 26 comparisons. In people who already trained it was 2.3 lb (1.05 kg), with an interval of 1.3 to 3.3 lb, from only four trials. [1] A beginner and a veteran are not being handed the same number.
And it is a 2018 number; the search behind it stopped in January 2017. The same research group’s 2022 update pooled 66 trials and 2,665 people for lean mass, put the gap at roughly 1.1 to 1.5 lb (0.5 to 0.7 kg), and graded the evidence moderate. [4] Both reviews carry industry ties, which are set out in the funding row of the panel above and in the source list below.
Who was in these trials matters as much as how many. Every one of them was doing resistance training at least twice a week, and none was dieting: the review took only healthy adults who were not in a calorie deficit. Fourteen of its study groups were women only. It found no difference between the sexes, in a comparison of 21 studies too imprecise to rule one out, and its authors say far less work has been done in women than in men. [1]
| Situation | Extra lean mass | Source |
| Lifting weights | +0.66 lb | 26 comparisons |
| Dieting | +0.79 lb | 14 comparisons, 12 with no lifting |
| Neither | no clear effect | 7 comparisons |
| Older adults (trial averages 61 to 85), no training | no clear effect | 7 comparisons |
Without lifting or dieting, no clear gain
This is the finding that should change what you buy. It comes from two separate meta-analyses that were not looking for the same thing, and it is narrower than “protein does nothing on its own”.
The first compared eating more protein than the RDA with eating the RDA itself — 0.8 g per kilogram of bodyweight a day (0.36 g per pound), about 65 g for someone weighing 180 lb — and sorted its trials by what the people in them were doing. [2] In the 14 comparisons of people who were dieting, 12 of them with no lifting, the extra protein was worth +0.79 lb of lean mass; the split is further down. In the three comparisons of people who were lifting it was +1.7 lb (0.77 kg) — but two of those three were dieting as well, so the two groups overlap, and the authors say three comparisons are too few to put a confident number on lifting by itself.
In the seven comparisons of people doing neither, the difference was 0.18 lb (0.08 kg), with a 95% confidence interval running from a loss of 1.3 lb to a gain of 1.65 lb (−0.59 to +0.75 kg). That range sits squarely on top of zero. It is also wide enough to hold a gain more than twice the size of the one the lifting trials found, which is why the honest phrase is not shown rather than nothing. Those seven were groups averaging 39 to 75 years old, followed for 10 to 24 weeks, and the authors warn that short trials and imprecise body-composition measurements push a result like this towards zero. [2] Their own summary: “The RDA for protein is adequate to support lean mass in adults during nonstressed states.”
The second looked only at older adults: 28 studies, in groups averaging 61 to 85 years old, none of them dieting. Without exercise, extra protein moved none of the three outcomes that had enough trials to pool — total lean mass (seven comparisons: 0.4 lb, or 0.18 kg, with an interval from −0.3 to +1.1 lb), arm and leg lean mass, grip strength. The one trial that measured knee strength without exercise, in frail participants, did find a gain, and the authors set it aside as a single result they could not explain. Add resistance exercise and two outcomes turned significant: arm and leg lean mass, and grip strength. Total lean mass did not, with exercise or without. [3]
Two larger reviews complicate the tidy version. The 2022 update of the 49-trial review found only six trials of extra protein without training in healthy adults who were not dieting. Pooled, their effect was about the same size as the one with training and its interval crossed zero, and the authors say six trials cannot support a proper analysis. [4] A 2021 review of 105 trials went further: across the 66 groups in its trials that did no resistance training, extra protein added 1.2 lb (0.53 kg) of lean mass, with a 95% confidence interval of 0.8 to 1.7 lb, about what it found with training. [5] Two things to know about that one. Forty-one of its 105 trials were weight-loss trials, which the 2022 authors point to as a likely reason the two reviews disagree. [4] And five of its seven authors are employees of Meiji, a food company whose SAVAS brand sells protein powders and drinks.
So here is what can be said. In the three pools that isolate people who were neither lifting nor dieting — seven comparisons, seven and six, which overlap — extra protein has not been shown to add lean mass, and none of the three was precise enough to rule it out. The protein is not the stimulus. It is the material. What the trials show clearly is what happens when something is asking the body to build, or to hold on to what it has.
The famous number was never statistically significant
If you have read anything about protein you have met 1.62 grams per kilogram of bodyweight — about 132 g a day for someone weighing 180 lb. It is quoted everywhere as the point where more protein stops helping.
It comes from the same 49-trial review. And here is what the authors actually wrote about it: the plateau analysis “is presented as a segmental regression despite not being statistically significant (p=0.079)”. [1]
Unpack that. They tested whether a bent line — rising, then flattening at a ceiling — described the data better than a plain straight one. It didn’t do so convincingly. p = 0.079 is just the wrong side of the line researchers use for “probably not chance”. They published the number anyway, and said so where they reported it: the caveat is in the results section and under the figure. The analysis rests on 42 groups of participants, 723 people, set side by side across different studies, and the authors call the plateau “unadjusted”. [1]
The label started coming off in the same paper. Its abstract, its conclusion and its summary box each state the plateau flatly, with no p value and no interval, and those are the parts a reader meets first. [1] In January 2026 the number reached federal guidance: the scientific report behind the new Dietary Guidelines for Americans cites this review for gains in people who train “with increasing daily protein intake up to approximately 1.6 g/kg body weight”, again with neither, and the guidelines set a protein goal of 1.2 to 1.6 g/kg a day. [6]
And the estimate comes with a 95% confidence interval — the range the true average ceiling probably sits in — of 1.03 to 2.20 g/kg. [1] That is uncertainty about where an average plateau sits across those 42 groups, not a span within which any one person’s ceiling falls. For someone weighing 180 lb the two ends work out to 84 g and 180 g a day. The groups themselves ate between 0.9 and 2.4 g/kg, so the interval covers most of the range the analysis had any data on. That is not a target. The authors, noting how wide the interval is, suggest about 2.2 g/kg for anyone trying to maximise their gains: that is the top of the interval, not a finding. [1]
Does it add less if you already eat plenty? The test pointed the other way
It is the intuitive idea: a supplement that closes a gap should do more for someone with a gap. The same paper tested it with a meta-regression — a check on whether the trials whose participants started out eating more protein found a bigger or a smaller effect. The result ran against the intuition. For each extra gram of protein per kilogram of bodyweight that people were already eating a day, the supplement’s added fat-free mass was 1.4 lb (0.64 kg) larger, not smaller, with a 95% confidence interval of 0.04 to 2.8 lb (0.02 to 1.27 kg), across 22 studies and 988 people. That was p = 0.045: just inside the line researchers use for “probably not chance”, where the ceiling’s 0.079 was just outside it. [1]
The authors do not take that at face value, and neither should you. They call it contrary to the theory and put it down to the trials in older adults, which started from lower intakes (about 1.2 against 1.5 g/kg a day) and also gave about half the supplement (20 g a day against 42). In the younger adults alone, how much people already ate made no detectable difference to what the supplement added. One unadjusted plot in the paper does lean the intuitive way: among younger adults, study groups that started out eating more protein gained less fat-free mass over the training. But that is each group’s own gain, supplemented or not, and it says nothing about what the supplement added. [1]
So this review did not find that people who already eat plenty get less from adding more. Its participants started at about 1.4 g/kg a day on average, three-quarters above the RDA, and the supplement still added fat-free mass. And when the authors checked whether trials with a bigger protein gap between the two groups found bigger gains, they did not (p = 0.99, 18 studies: no sign of a relationship at all). [1] Whatever the truth about diminishing returns, this paper is not the evidence for them.
If you are over 45, read this bit twice
Extra protein is advocated for older adults on the sarcopenia argument — muscle loss with age. [3] So this is worth stating carefully, because the reviews do not say quite the same thing.
In the 49-trial review, the fat-free mass benefit in the trials of people over 45 was 0.13 lb (0.06 kg), with a 95% confidence interval of −0.3 to +0.6 lb (−0.14 to +0.26 kg) — no clear effect. In the trials of people under 45 it was +1.2 lb (0.55 kg). The gap between the two age groups was itself statistically significant. [1] But look at who those groups were. The “over 45” trials averaged 67 years old and the “under 45” ones 24; there were only 13 of the older trials; and they gave about half the supplement, 20 g a day against 42. The authors call that dose surprisingly low and the missing effect perhaps not surprising. [1] Their 2022 update found no significant difference between age groups, and a small effect in people of 65 and over eating 1.2 to 1.59 g/kg a day that disappears when one trial is left out. [4]
The older-adult review is more encouraging, but only on one condition: protein plus resistance exercise did increase arm and leg lean mass (+1.2 lb) and grip strength. Protein alone did not. And the lean-mass benefit showed up only in people who were already frail or sarcopenic (+1.9 lb). [3]
Worth knowing before you weigh that: the authors record that “Most studies (n = 22) had some risk of bias” — 22 of their 28 — and most of the spread between the trials’ results was more than chance would produce. I-squared, the share of that spread luck does not explain, came to 90% for arm and leg lean mass and 95% for grip strength. That is not a count of which way the trials pointed, so we read the charts too. With exercise, four of the five arm-and-leg results favour protein and one favours the comparison group; on grip, two favour protein clearly and two sit on the comparison group’s side, both with ranges that include no difference. [3] This is not a settled corner of the literature. It is a noisy one, in which most of the results with exercise land on protein’s side.
The RDA review adds one more older-adult result, and it is the largest of the three: in its five comparisons limited to people over 50, eating more than the RDA went with 2.0 lb (0.91 kg) more lean mass, with a 95% confidence interval of 0.5 to 3.5 lb. Those five mixed dieters, lifters, both and neither, which the authors say stopped them separating the conditions. [2]
Where it clearly earns its keep
One situation comes out of all this looking genuinely good, and it is probably the one you are in if you are on this site.
Dieting. When people were in a calorie deficit, eating more protein than the RDA — about 1.3 against 0.8 g/kg a day — preserved an extra 0.79 lb of lean mass (0.36 kg), with a 95% confidence interval of 0.1 to 1.5 lb, across 14 comparisons. [2]
Does that need the gym? Twelve of those 14 comparisons involved no lifting at all. On their own they came to 0.55 lb (0.25 kg), with an interval that includes zero (−0.2 to +1.3 lb), and the two that added lifting came to 1.4 lb (0.65 kg). So in this review the diet-only result points the same way without being clear by itself. The pooled figure is what reaches significance, and the authors read it as holding with and without lifting. [2]
Losing weight costs you some lean mass along with the fat. Protein reduces the bill. That is a modest, real, well-evidenced benefit, and it does not need a single exaggeration to be worth acting on.
The verdict
Established. The rating attaches to one finding: extra protein adds a small amount of lean mass in people doing resistance training. The 2018 review found it in 26 comparisons, and the same group’s 2022 update found it again in 62 trials and graded the evidence moderate. [1] [4] It is an average, and it is clearest in younger adults and in people who already train: for beginners and for people of 65 and over the pooled gains were smaller, with ranges that reach zero. The RDA review agrees from just three lifting comparisons, and the older-adult review agrees for arm and leg lean mass and grip strength, though not for total lean mass. [2] [3] Strength moves too: 5.5 lb (2.49 kg) more on a one-rep max, the heaviest single lift a person can manage, which the 2018 authors put at about 9% of what the training delivered. [1] The reviews are not fully independent of one another, either: they pool some of the same trials.
What is not established is the size everyone imagines, or the ceiling everyone quotes. And what it does with no training and no diet has not been pinned down either way: the pooled results are too imprecise to show a gain or to rule one out.
So: if you lift, or you are dieting, more protein helps by a small and measurable amount. If you do neither, one review tested eating more than the RDA directly and found no measurable difference across seven comparisons, and the older-adult review points the same way for lean mass and grip strength. [2] [3] That is an absence of evidence that the tub does anything for you, not proof that it cannot.
And how much? The evidence does not hand you a target. In the lifting trials that recorded it, the supplement groups ended up at about 1.8 g/kg a day and the others at about 1.3 — roughly 147 g against 106 g at 180 lb — and both started well above the RDA. [1] The dieting trials compared about 1.3 g/kg with 0.8. [2] The federal guidelines published in January 2026 set a goal of 1.2 to 1.6 g/kg a day, which is 98 to 131 g at 180 lb. [6] More than the RDA helps if you lift or diet. Where the help stops is the part nobody has established.
The training is the active ingredient. The powder is the supporting cast, and it has spent a long time being billed as the lead.
Related: does protein keep you full · how much creatine should you take · does lifting weights burn fat · does cardio burn muscle · collagen benefits · every claim we’ve checked
This page was corrected on 30 September 2026 after an independent editorial review, and four things it said were wrong. It said protein does “nothing” without training. The two reviews it cited found no clear effect in people who were neither lifting nor dieting, from seven comparisons each, with ranges wide enough to include a gain larger than the one lifters get; the dieting benefit it reported comes from a pool in which most comparisons involved no lifting; and a 2021 review it did not cite found a gain without training. The heading, the search description, the table and the verdict no longer say “nothing”; they say what was and was not shown, and for whom. It said people who already eat more protein get less from a supplement, citing a test (p = 0.045) that pointed the other way; that section now reports the direction the paper found and how its authors explain it. It said two of its three sources were behind paywalls and had been read from their abstracts. Both are free to read; we have now read them in full, and that changed the knee-strength sentence, the older-adult row of the table and the account of the dieting and lifting results. And its funding row said “not stated”. All three reviews carry statements, and two declare ties to dairy or supplement businesses, which are now named in the panel and the source list.
Also changed: the 0.66 lb is dated to the 2018 review, given with its confidence interval and the 26 comparisons it rests on, and set beside the same group’s 2022 update; the split between new and experienced lifters, the ages and doses behind the over-45 result and the thin evidence in women are stated; the 1.03 to 2.20 interval is described as uncertainty about an average rather than a personal range, and its upper end at 180 lb is 180 g, not 179; the RDA is given as a number; and the evidence trail now says the paper’s own abstract drops the caveat first, names the January 2026 federal guidance as a dated place it was dropped again, and attaches the search-volume figure to the query it was measured for. One sentence about how protein is marketed to older adults had no source and was replaced. The rating is unchanged: Established, for the finding that extra protein adds a small amount of lean mass in people who lift.
Corrected on 9 October 2026. The provenance chain gave a search figure, 18,100 US searches a month for “how much protein per day”, with the date of our pull but not where it came from. It comes from a paid keyword database, pulled on 27 July 2026, and the chain now says so. The rating is unchanged.
Corrected on 23 October 2026. Of the review of older adults, we wrote that its trials “disagreed with each other enormously” and that the literature was noisy “with a consistent direction”. The numbers behind the first phrase, I-squared figures of 90% and 95%, are the share of the spread between trials’ results that is more than chance would produce; they do not say whether the trials agree. The review’s charts, read in its authors’ accepted manuscript, show the direction was not consistent either: with exercise, one of five arm-and-leg results and two of four grip results sit on the comparison group’s side. The paragraph now says both. No figure we had printed changes, and the rating is unchanged: Established, for the finding that extra protein adds a small amount of lean mass in people who lift.


