Claims checked

236 verdicts
3 of 3cavity trials of fluoride-free hydroxyapatite against fluoride were funded by the paste's maker; each found it no worseMAYBEPreliminary

Hydroxyapatite Toothpaste: It Matched Fluoride in Three Cavity Trials. The Paste’s Maker Funded All Three

Data graphic: the share who got new decay on a fluoride-free hydroxyapatite paste against fluoride in three trials. Children over a year, 72.7% against 74.2%; patients with new braces over about six months, 56.8% against 60.9%; adults over 18 months, 10.7% against 12.6%. All three trials were funded by the paste's maker. Beside it the figure 3 of 3

Is hydroxyapatite toothpaste as good as fluoride? In the three trials that put a fluoride-free one against fluoride and counted new decay, it did no worse, and one independent pooling found no difference. All three were funded by the company that makes the paste they tested, none had a plain-toothpaste group, and none ran past 18 months. The EU's safety committee calls the nano form safe in toothpaste.

1 lbof fat added a year during the menopause transition, up from about half a pound before it, while the scale kept its old pace (SWAN, 1,246 women, body scans)MOSTLYSupported

Menopause Weight Gain: The Scale Doesn’t Speed Up at Menopause. Fat Gain Nearly Doubles, and Muscle Starts to Go

Data graphic from the SWAN study of 1,246 women: fat rose 0.25 kg a year before the menopause transition and 0.45 kg a year during it; lean mass rose 0.06 kg a year before and fell 0.06 kg a year during; weight rose 0.25 kg a year during, the same pace as before. Beside it the figure 1 lb

Does menopause cause weight gain? In the largest US study that scanned women through it, the scale kept climbing at the same steady pace it had before. What changed was the weight itself: fat went on nearly twice as fast, about 1 lb a year, muscle started to fall, and fat moved toward the waist. Hormone therapy neither adds weight nor takes it off.

1.4xthe energy cost of a flat 2.5 mph walk carrying 40 lb, against the same walk without it (Compendium of Physical Activities). Sold as 2 to 3 timesNOUnsupported

Rucking: It Burns More Than Walking, but Not 2 to 3 Times More. A Pack a Quarter of Your Weight Added About a Quarter

Data graphic: the energy of a walk against the same walk with no pack. The seller's example, 2.6 times; a 40 lb pack on a flat 2.5 mph walk, 1.4 times; a pack at a quarter of body weight outdoors, 1.26 times; climbing a 6 to 10% hill with no pack, 2 times. Beside it the figure 1.4x

Rucking is walking with weight on your back, and it does burn more than walking without it: in a field study, a pack worth a quarter of body weight added about a quarter to the energy cost of the same walk at the same pace. Its biggest seller says two to three times; that figure needs a hill. Whether rucking takes off more fat than walking has not been tested in a published trial we could find.

Under 2.2 lbmore weight lost on AOD-9604 than on a dummy pill, at every dose, in its 536-person, 24-week trial (under 1 kg; the developer's figure)NOUnsupported

Peptides for Weight Loss: The Ones That Work Are Prescription Drugs. AOD-9604, the ‘Fat-Loss Peptide’ Sold Online, Failed Its Own 536-Person Trial

Data graphic: in a 24-week trial of 536 adults, AOD-9604 was built to detect 1.8 kg (4 lb) more weight loss than a dummy pill and found under 1 kg (2.2 lb) at every dose; beside it the figure Under 2.2 lb

Some peptides cause real weight loss: semaglutide and tirzepatide took off about 15% and up to 21% of body weight in their main trials, and both are prescription drugs. AOD-9604, sold online as the fat-loss peptide, beat a dummy pill by under 1 kg (2.2 lb) at every dose in a 536-person trial, and its developer dropped it in 2007. BPC-157 and MOTS-c have no published human weight-loss trial we could find, and tests of vials sold online find many fail basic quality checks.

2.8 mg/dLfall in fasting blood sugar over 12 weeks on 2.4 g of moringa leaf a day, against a 2.0 mg/dL rise on a dummy pill, in a double-blind trial of 65 adults with prediabetes (Madrid, 2021)MAYBEPreliminary

Moringa Benefits: A Nutritious Leaf With Small, Mixed Blood Sugar Trials

Data graphic: fasting blood sugar over 12 weeks in a Madrid trial of 65 adults with prediabetes, 103.4 to 100.6 mg/dL on moringa and 104.2 to 106.2 on a dummy pill; beside them the figure 2.8 mg/dL

Moringa leaf is genuinely nutritious, gram for gram. Sold as a blood sugar remedy, it put fasting sugar a few mg/dL below placebo in some small trials and not in others, and a 2025 pooling of randomised trials found no significant difference. Weight did not move; the breast milk evidence is small and mixed; pregnancy and contaminated powders are the real cautions.

24% lowerdeath rate from heart disease and stroke, men eating the most natto against men eating none (hazard ratio 0.76; women 0.79, 21% lower), 92,915 Japanese adults; an association, not a testMAYBEPreliminary

Natto Benefits: Linked to Fewer Heart and Stroke Deaths. No Trial We Found Has Tested It

Data graphic: in a Japanese study of 92,915 adults followed for 14.8 years, people eating the most natto against none had death rates from heart disease and stroke 0.76 times as high in men (range 0.65 to 0.90) and 0.79 in women (0.65 to 0.95), both clear of the no-difference line; beside them the figure 24% lower

In two large Japanese studies, people who ate the most natto died of heart disease and stroke at about a fifth to a quarter lower rate than people who ate little or none. That is an association, not a test. The enzyme pill sold from natto, nattokinase, lowered blood pressure a few points in two small trials tied to its makers but not significantly in two others, and in its three-year trial did not significantly slow artery thickening. If you take warfarin, natto's vitamin K works against your drug.

2small tests of biotin alone, with a comparison, that we found in people without a deficiency: 46 women for four weeks (1966, against a dummy pill) and 10 healthy men for 14 days (2024, each against himself). Neither found a significant gain: in 2024 hair length went from 2.50 to 2.47 mm a week and hair cover from 2.22% to 2.68% of a shaved patch a day, each not a significant changeNOUnsupported

Biotin for Hair Growth: It Regrows Hair Lost to a Deficiency. Without One, the Two Small Tests of Biotin Alone We Found Showed No Significant Gain.

Data graphic: the two tests of biotin alone in people without a deficiency, a 1966 trial of 46 women against a dummy pill for four weeks and a 2024 test of 10 men for two weeks, each marked as finding no significant gain in hair; beneath, no longer controlled test found in people with thinning hair; beside them the figure 2

Biotin brings back hair lost to a biotin deficiency, which is rare. In people who are not short of it, the two small tests of biotin alone we found showed no significant gain, and doses sold for hair can make some blood tests wrong, including one used to diagnose heart attacks.

2 yearsthe longest placebo-controlled trial of DHEA we read, in 144 people aged 60 and over, 56 of them on DHEA: strength and quality of life did not significantly improve, and body composition did not change significantly in men or women analysed separatelyNOUnsupported

DHEA Benefits: Two Years Restored the Hormone, Not Strength or Quality of Life

Data graphic: a two-year axis for a placebo-controlled trial of 144 people aged 60 and over, 29 men and 27 women on DHEA, 31 men and 30 women on a dummy pill and 27 men on testosterone; the hormone level was raised throughout, and strength and quality of life were not significantly better than on the dummy pill; beside them the figure 2 years

DHEA pills reliably raise hormone levels, testosterone mostly in women. In trials of older adults up to two years long, strength and quality of life did not significantly improve, and older men lost 0.9 lb of fat in a year. The prescription vaginal form is a different product.

181people analysed in the biggest trial we found to measure inflammation and oxidation markers: three months of electrolysed hydrogen water or filtered water from look-alike machines; CRP, IL-6, TNF and five other blood and urine markers, all side outcomes, were not significantly different between the groupsMAYBEPreliminary

Hydrogen Water Benefits: Small, Mixed Shifts in Blood Markers, and No Significant Win in the Three Biggest Trials

Data graphic: one dot per person in a 2024 Japanese trial of 181 adults with or near metabolic syndrome, 91 on electrolysed hydrogen water and 90 on filtered water for three months; eight inflammation and oxidation markers, all side outcomes, none significantly different between the groups; beside them the figure 181

Hydrogen water is real: the gas is in fresh water, and it leaks out within hours. Small trials found small, mixed shifts in blood markers of inflammation and oxidation; the three biggest, of 700, 200 and 178 people, found no significant difference on their main outcome.

196 vs 248rise in coronary calcium score over two years on K2 with D3 vs a dummy pill, 398 people with heavy calciumMAYBEPreliminary

Vitamin D3 and K2: Artery Calcium Still Rose, a Fifth Slower in the Largest Trial

Data graphic: in a two-year Danish trial of 398 people with heavy calcium in the heart's arteries, the calcium score rose by 196 units on vitamin K2 with D3 and by 248 on a dummy pill; beside them the figure 196 vs 248

Sold to steer calcium into bone and out of the arteries. In the largest trial of the pair, 398 people with heavy artery calcium, it still built up, about a fifth more slowly than on a dummy pill; in a trial of 365 men it did not build up significantly more slowly. On warfarin, K2 is a drug interaction.